EVs vs Hybrids: Which is Better for South African Drivers?

Choosing between EVs and hybrids in South Africa depends on your priorities: cost, driving needs, and available infrastructure. Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Cost: Hybrids are more affordable upfront (e.g., Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid at $27,400) compared to EVs like the Mini Cooper SE ($39,400). However, EVs save more on fuel – up to $1,700 annually.
• Infrastructure: Hybrids benefit from South Africa’s extensive fuel station network, while EVs rely on a growing but limited charging network (500+ public chargers, mostly in cities). Load shedding and rural access remain challenges for EVs.
• Environment: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions but depend on South Africa’s coal-heavy grid, which currently makes hybrids a greener option overall.
• Driving Needs: Hybrids are better for long trips and rural areas. EVs excel in cities with access to reliable home or workplace charging.

Quick Comparison

Bottom Line: If you need flexibility and affordability, go hybrid. If you have access to reliable charging and want lower running costs over time, consider an EV.

Cost Analysis and Running Expenses

Purchase Price Differences

In South Africa, the initial cost of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to hybrid cars highlights a noticeable gap. Hybrids provide a more budget-friendly way to adopt greener driving practices.

Take the Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid, for example – it starts at $27,400 (R486,100). On the other hand, the Mini Cooper SE, a fully electric option, comes in just under $39,400 (R700,000). That’s about $12,000 (R213,900) more for going fully electric.

This price difference stems largely from the current costs tied to battery technology and production. While EV prices are expected to decline as manufacturing scales up globally, hybrids currently strike a balance between affordability, fuel savings, and reduced emissions without the steep upfront investment. Let’s dive into how these options compare in terms of maintenance and day-to-day expenses.

Maintenance and Operating Expenses

When it comes to upkeep, hybrids sit between traditional petrol cars and EVs, but they come with their own set of factors to consider. Maintenance needs for hybrids are similar to conventional vehicles, but their advanced technology and specialized parts can lead to higher repair costs if issues arise.

That said, hybrids often enjoy lower maintenance costs compared to petrol cars. For instance, their electric components experience less wear, and regenerative braking systems help extend brake pad life, cutting down overall maintenance expenses.

The main concern for hybrid owners is battery replacement. While most hybrid batteries come with warranties lasting eight years or up to 99,400 miles (160,000 km), replacing them outside of warranty can be pricey. It’s also essential to service hybrids at authorized centers familiar with their unique combination of internal combustion and electric systems.

EVs, by contrast, tend to have simpler and cheaper maintenance over the long term. Electric motors have far fewer moving parts than combustion engines, eliminating the need for oil changes, spark plugs, and similar services. However, finding qualified EV technicians and parts can be tricky, especially outside major cities in South Africa.

While running costs vary, government incentives can help offset some of the financial burden.

Government Incentives and Tax Benefits

South Africa’s government has introduced various incentives to encourage EV adoption, though many are geared more toward manufacturers than individual consumers.

One of the most impactful measures is a 150% tax deduction for investments in electric and hydrogen-powered vehicle production, starting in March 2026. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana emphasized this initiative as a way to boost local EV manufacturing, with the allowance capped at $26.9 million for the 2026/27 tax year.

To encourage production of EVs in South Africa, the government will introduce an investment allowance for new investments, beginning 1 March 2026.

– Enoch Godongwana, South Africa’s Finance Minister

For consumers, there are some tax advantages. EVs are exempt from carbon tax and enjoy full VAT exemption on sales. Additionally, customs duties on EVs and related components are waived, and businesses can benefit from accelerated depreciation allowances for EV fleet purchases.

However, a key hurdle remains: EVs face higher import duties – 25% compared to 18% for combustion vehicles. Industry group CHARGE has criticized this policy, arguing that it undermines the government’s green initiatives:

This incentive to boost local manufacturing is a positive step forward, but we also need to reduce the current high import duties for EVs – 25% compared to 18% for combustion engine vehicles. These taxes inflate EV prices, slow demand, and limit market growth.

– CHARGE

President Cyril Ramaphosa has also acknowledged the need for broader consumer-focused incentives, stating:

Consideration must be given to incentives for manufacturers, as well as tax rebates or subsidies for consumers, to accelerate the uptake of electric vehicles.

– President Cyril Ramaphosa

Hybrids, on the other hand, receive fewer direct incentives but still benefit from lower fuel costs and some general green vehicle tax breaks. The government’s broader focus seems to be on steering the market toward full electrification. Additional measures, such as infrastructure incentives for businesses investing in EV charging networks and tax credits for EV technology research, are expected to make charging more accessible and affordable over time.

These factors are crucial for South African drivers trying to balance financial constraints with their desire to drive greener vehicles.

EV, Plug-In, or Hybrid: Which Should You Buy in 2025?!

Charging Stations and Fuel Access

The infrastructure for electric vehicles (EVs) and hybrids in South Africa paints two very different pictures. Hybrid drivers benefit from the country’s extensive fuel station network, while EV owners face challenges like limited charging stations and the ongoing issue of grid reliability.

EV Charging Network Status

As of May 30, 2025, South Africa has over 500 public EV chargers in operation. These stations are concentrated in major cities like Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Pretoria, with fast-charging corridors being developed along key highways, including the N1, N3, and N4.

However, load shedding remains a persistent hurdle, creating uncertainty for EV owners who rely on consistent power. To address this, GridCars reports that 42% of its chargers are now solar-powered.

In a significant development, Zero Carbon Charge introduced its first off-grid, solar-powered EV charging station in Wolmaransstad, North West Province, in November 2024. Backed by a $5.6 million (R100 million) equity investment from the Development Bank of Southern Africa, the company plans to roll out 120 stations by September 2025. These stations will be spaced approximately every 93 miles (150 km) along South Africa’s major national roads.

"… there’s a stronger use of home charging, but that’s because there aren’t consumer-based stations where you can travel across the country with peace of mind."
– Larissa Venter, Chief Stakeholder Officer at Zero Carbon Charge

The cost of building charging stations is steep. A single EV charging station can range from $28,100 to $112,400 (R500,000 to R2 million). For example, a 200kW DC charger at Mall of Africa in Johannesburg cost around $140,500 (R2.5 million), while a 150kW DC charger at Canal Walk in Cape Town required about $84,300 (R1.5 million).

Despite the challenges, industry leaders remain optimistic. Winstone Jordaan, Director of GridCars, emphasizes the importance of laying the groundwork now:

"We need about 100,000 vehicles on the road before any of us will see real profitability. But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t build the foundation now."
– Winstone Jordaan, Director of GridCars

While EV owners grapple with these obstacles, hybrid drivers enjoy the convenience of a well-established fuel infrastructure.

Fuel Station Access for Hybrids

Unlike EVs, hybrids take full advantage of South Africa’s extensive fuel station network. Drivers can refuel almost anywhere in the country within minutes, without worrying about grid issues or load shedding. This accessibility is especially beneficial in rural areas where EV charging options are scarce, eliminating range anxiety and the need for meticulous trip planning.

Charging vs Fueling Comparison Table

Here’s a quick look at how charging EVs stacks up against refueling hybrids:

For EV owners, smart charging is crucial. Experts recommend charging during stable electricity periods and using smart chargers to protect batteries from power fluctuations. Home charging remains the most reliable option, costing about $0.14–$0.20 (R2.50–R3.50) per kWh, though this depends on consistent power availability and the ability to install a charger at home.

This disparity in infrastructure explains why EVs currently represent just 1.2% of new car sales in South Africa, even though sales have grown by over 80% year-on-year between 2023 and 2025. Up next, we’ll dive into fuel economy and driving performance on South African roads.

Fuel Economy and Driving Performance

EVs and hybrids each bring distinct advantages when it comes to operating costs and performance, especially when navigating South Africa’s diverse driving conditions.

Energy Use and Fuel Economy

Electric vehicles (EVs) are impressively cost-efficient. They typically consume 15–18 kWh per 62 miles, which translates to about $2.20–$2.80 (R40–R50) in electricity costs. In comparison, covering the same distance in a gasoline-powered car costs approximately $10.10–$12.40 (R180–R220). That’s more than a 75% savings in energy costs.

Hybrids, while not as energy-efficient as EVs, still offer solid fuel savings compared to traditional vehicles. For instance, the Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid achieves 4.3 liters per 62 miles (100 km), a notable improvement over the 6.8 liters used by its gasoline-only counterpart – a 37% difference. Real-world tests showed the hybrid consumed just over 6.0 liters per 62 miles in city driving and 5.6 liters on a 745-mile (1,200 km) highway journey.

Other hybrids demonstrate similar results. The Honda Fit 1.5 e.HEV, for example, uses 3.7 liters per 62 miles, compared to 5.5 liters for the non-hybrid version. The Haval Jolion Pro 1.5 HEV achieves 5.1 liters per 62 miles, outperforming its turbocharged alternative, which consumes 7.5 liters.

For context, some of the most fuel-efficient conventional cars in South Africa – like the Ford Fiesta 1.5 TDCi at 3.3 liters per 62 miles and the Volkswagen Polo 1.6 TDI at 4.0 liters – come close to hybrid efficiency on paper. However, these diesel models lack the urban efficiency boost provided by electric motors.

These fuel efficiency figures highlight how EVs and hybrids adapt to South Africa’s varied driving environments.

Performance on South African Roads

South Africa’s diverse driving conditions – ranging from urban traffic to long highway stretches – play to the strengths of both EVs and hybrids, albeit in different ways. EVs thrive in city settings, where frequent stops and starts enable them to recover energy through regenerative braking. Hybrids, however, excel in mixed driving scenarios. They seamlessly switch between electric power for city driving and gasoline for sustained highway cruising, making them a practical choice for long-distance travel in areas where charging stations remain sparse.

A notable demonstration of hybrid endurance occurred in February 2025, when JAECOO and OMODA showcased plug-in hybrids completing a 683-mile (1,100 km) journey from Cape Town to Gqeberha without needing to refuel or recharge.

That said, plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) do face some challenges on extended highway trips. Once the battery is depleted, they can become less efficient than traditional combustion engine vehicles at high speeds. For instance, a BMW iX1 used up 90% of its battery over a 148-mile (238 km) stretch at a steady 73 mph (117 km/h).

In mountainous areas, such as the Drakensberg passes or coastal routes, maintaining control on steep descents is essential. Diesel engines tend to offer superior engine braking due to their higher compression ratios. Meanwhile, hybrids and EVs rely on regenerative braking systems to achieve similar control, making them effective even on challenging terrain.

Regenerative Braking Benefits

Regenerative braking is a standout feature in EVs and hybrids. It captures energy during deceleration and converts it into electrical power, which extends battery range and reduces wear on traditional brakes.

"Regenerative braking is a simple process used by self-charging hybrid cars. It allows them to recharge their batteries using braking power." – Honda

This system can recover up to 70% of the kinetic energy typically lost during braking. Over time, this translates into hundreds of extra miles of electric driving annually, enhancing overall efficiency.

Regenerative braking works best in stop-and-go traffic, making it especially useful in congested city centers during rush hour. Both EVs and hybrids benefit from this technology, though its effectiveness depends on driving habits and speeds. To maximize its potential, drivers should aim to anticipate traffic patterns and decelerate smoothly rather than relying on sudden, hard braking. With practice, this approach becomes second nature, allowing drivers to tap into the full benefits of regenerative braking.

Ultimately, the differences in performance between EVs and hybrids go far beyond fuel economy. They reflect how these vehicles adapt to South Africa’s unique driving challenges and energy landscape.

sbb-itb-09752ea

Carbon Footprint and Emissions

The environmental impact of electric vehicles (EVs) and hybrids in South Africa is a layered issue with no one-size-fits-all answer.

Direct Emissions and Lifecycle Impact

EVs stand out for their zero tailpipe emissions, which contribute to cleaner air in urban areas. However, their overall environmental impact becomes more nuanced when considering the entire lifecycle. Hybrids, while producing emissions, still outperform traditional gasoline vehicles in terms of reduced direct emissions.

The manufacturing process reveals key differences. Producing an EV requires twice as many natural resources as a conventional car, largely due to the energy-intensive process of making batteries. In fact, battery production accounts for 40–50% of an EV’s total carbon footprint, with nearly 19% of the energy demand coming from the production of battery cells alone.

Over time, EVs begin to compensate for their higher manufacturing emissions. After driving approximately 15,000 miles (24,140 km), their overall carbon footprint becomes lower than that of a conventional vehicle. This efficiency is largely due to EVs converting 87–91% of battery energy into motion, compared to gasoline vehicles, which only convert 16–25% of fuel energy.

Hybrids fall between the two extremes. Plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) reduce well-to-wheel emissions by 59–68%, while regular hybrids offer reductions of 12–46%. When looking at tank-to-wheel emissions, PHEVs cut emissions by 74–81%, and regular hybrids achieve reductions of 38–56%.

These lifecycle differences highlight the importance of South Africa’s energy mix in shaping the emissions profiles of EVs and hybrids.

South Africa’s Coal-Heavy Power Grid

The operational emissions of EVs are deeply influenced by the electricity grid they rely on. South Africa’s grid, heavily dependent on coal, creates unique challenges. The country’s electricity generation has a carbon intensity of 950 g CO2 per kWh, more than double that of the European Union at 429 g CO2 per kWh. Charging an EV in South Africa generates emissions at a rate of 1,002 g CO2e per kWh.

This reliance on coal leads to a surprising outcome: charging an EV in South Africa currently results in higher emissions than driving a new gasoline-powered car. A typical gasoline car produces around 4.4 tonnes of CO2 annually, while an EV charged on the national grid generates 5.8 tonnes. This is because coal accounts for 80% of the country’s electricity production.

The future, however, looks more promising. By 2050, renewable energy is expected to supply 76% of South Africa’s electricity, reducing carbon intensity to 139 g per kWh. As the grid becomes greener, EVs will deliver much greater environmental benefits. Starting in 2040, the combination of a cleaner grid and more widespread EV adoption is projected to significantly lower emissions.

By 2050, EVs are expected to cut passenger car greenhouse gas emissions by 19%, while internal combustion engine vehicles will still account for 63% of emissions. This is particularly important for South Africa, where road transport produced 59.49 million metric tons of CO2e in 2019, with passenger cars contributing nearly half of that total.

Emissions Comparison Table

*Estimated based on emission reduction percentages and future grid projections

The environmental benefits of EVs are deeply tied to the carbon intensity of the electricity grid they rely on. Urban areas experience the immediate advantage of reduced air pollution from EVs, while rural regions may bear the brunt of environmental impacts from nearby power plants.

For those seeking immediate reductions in emissions, hybrids offer a practical solution. However, as South Africa transitions to renewable energy, EVs will become the better choice for long-term environmental gains.

Best Choice for Different Driver Types

South African drivers have unique priorities shaped by their daily routines, living conditions, and financial considerations. These factors play a key role in determining the most suitable vehicle for various driving scenarios.

Urban Daily Commuters

Electric vehicles (EVs) shine in city traffic, where frequent stops and starts allow for energy regeneration, resulting in lower running costs and reduced maintenance . Take the BYD Dolphin, priced at R539,900 – it’s a practical option for urban drivers with access to home or workplace charging. On the other hand, hybrids like the Suzuki Grand Vitara 1.5 Hybrid (R358,900) and Toyota Corolla Cross 1.8 XS HEV (R500,200) offer immediate fuel savings without the worry of charging infrastructure, making them ideal for those who can’t rely on consistent charging options.

Interestingly, traditional hybrids have gained significant traction in South Africa. In early 2024, they dominated the country’s new-energy vehicle market, with over 3,000 units sold. Hybrid sales also saw a 63.4% jump in 2023 compared to the previous year .

"Traditional hybrids will help city commuters reduce fuel costs and be able to take a road trip when desired. PHEVs, on the other hand, are better suited for people living in houses where they can access a charging station. If you want to get a full EV one day, this option prepares you for it."

• Keletso Mpisane, Head of Blink by MiWay

For city drivers focused on cutting fuel expenses and embracing cleaner air, hybrids strike a balance by removing range anxiety while still offering environmental perks. Meanwhile, EVs can be a cost-effective option for those with short commutes and dependable home charging, despite their higher initial price.

Long-Distance Road Trip Drivers

While EVs excel in urban settings, long-distance travel presents challenges that hybrids are better equipped to handle. The convenience of widespread fuel stations makes hybrids a reliable choice for extended road trips, especially in remote areas.

South Africa’s EV charging network has expanded, with providers like GridCars and Rubicon offering over 350 charge points nationwide. However, EV drivers still need to plan routes carefully to avoid issues like load-shedding and limited rural coverage .

GridCars CEO Winstone Jordaan remarked, "Any EV with a 200km or greater range could drive from Johannesburg to Cape Town using our network" as of 2019 . Fast chargers have been strategically placed at fuel stations and in smaller towns, with Rubicon contributing 110 chargers, nearly half of which support DC fast charging .

For drivers who frequently travel long distances, hybrids deliver the flexibility and peace of mind that EVs are still working to provide consistently.

Drivers Without Home Charging

For those living in apartments, housing complexes, or areas with unreliable electricity, owning an EV can be challenging. Public charging infrastructure is still limited, often concentrated in wealthier neighborhoods, leaving many drivers without convenient options. Hybrids, however, bypass these hurdles entirely by not requiring external charging.

Standard hybrids operate without the need for charging, while plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) can function as traditional hybrids when charging isn’t available. This adaptability has made hybrids the top choice in South Africa’s electric vehicle market, with 2,574 units sold in Q1 2024 alone.

Cost is another factor. While EVs can offer lower operational costs when charged at home, those relying on public charging face higher expenses and added inconvenience. Hybrids, on the other hand, provide immediate savings on fuel without the need for additional infrastructure, making them a practical and efficient choice for many South African drivers.

Ultimately, your ideal vehicle depends on your driving habits, access to charging, and the reliability of the infrastructure in your area. Hybrids and EVs both offer compelling benefits, but the right fit comes down to your specific circumstances.

Conclusion

In reviewing the options for South African drivers, three key factors – affordability, infrastructure, and environmental considerations – stand out. Deciding between electric vehicles (EVs) and hybrids ultimately comes down to your personal circumstances, driving habits, and access to essential infrastructure. These elements highlight the varied needs of drivers across the country and provide a framework for making an informed decision.

Hybrids offer a practical and budget-friendly way to step into greener driving. They come with a lower upfront cost compared to EVs, while still delivering improved fuel efficiency and reduced emissions.

"With the high price of EVs, a hybrid vehicle might be a steppingstone towards all-electric, offering two clear benefits: enhanced fuel efficiency and lower emissions. While the country grapples with ongoing electricity issues and better infrastructure for EVs is installed, hybrid cars are a good transitional option." – Barend Smit, Marketing Director of MotorHappy

For those who can make it work, EVs bring unique advantages. Urban drivers with access to home charging stations can benefit from significantly lower running costs, which may offset the higher purchase price within three to five years.

Infrastructure remains a key consideration. While EVs are supported by a growing charging network, hybrids rely on South Africa’s well-established fuel infrastructure, making them more versatile in areas where EV charging may still be limited.

From an environmental perspective, EVs eliminate tailpipe emissions, but the country’s coal-heavy energy grid reduces their overall impact. This makes hybrids a practical middle ground for drivers looking to reduce their carbon footprint while South Africa transitions to cleaner energy sources.

To sum it up, hybrids are a better fit for drivers who frequently travel long distances, live in rural areas, or lack access to reliable home charging. On the other hand, EVs make more sense for urban commuters with dependable charging options and shorter daily drives.

As South Africa’s EV market is expected to grow from $471.3 million in 2025 to about $1.01 billion by 2029, the landscape is set to change rapidly. Your choice today could influence both your long-term savings and your contribution to a more sustainable future.

FAQs

Does South Africa’s reliance on coal power reduce the environmental benefits of electric vehicles?

South Africa’s coal-dependent energy grid does pose a challenge to the environmental promise of electric vehicles (EVs). With the majority of the country’s electricity generated from coal, charging an EV often leads to substantial greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. In some cases, these emissions can rival or even exceed those produced by traditional gas-powered vehicles. This reliance on coal limits the immediate ability of EVs to significantly cut carbon footprints.

That said, the outlook improves as South Africa gradually shifts toward renewable energy. Over time, as cleaner energy sources take a larger share of the grid, the environmental benefits of EVs are likely to become more pronounced. For now, how much EVs can help the environment largely depends on the speed of this energy transition.

What should South African drivers consider when choosing between an EV and a hybrid for long-distance travel?

When weighing the decision between an electric vehicle (EV) and a hybrid for long trips in South Africa, there are several factors to keep in mind:

• Charging vs. Refueling: EVs depend on charging stations, which can be hard to find outside urban areas. In contrast, hybrids can be refueled at any gas station, making them a more convenient option for remote travel.
• Driving Range: EVs typically cover 125–155 miles per charge, requiring careful planning for extended journeys. Hybrids, such as the Toyota Corolla Cross, can go over 310 miles on a full tank, offering greater peace of mind.
• Fuel Costs and Electricity Availability: While EVs are cheaper to operate thanks to lower electricity costs, hybrids provide flexibility by switching to gas – a handy feature in regions where electricity supply is unreliable.
• Environmental Considerations: EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, but their overall impact depends on South Africa’s coal-heavy energy grid. Hybrids, though not emission-free, are still a cleaner choice than traditional gas-powered vehicles.
• Maintenance: EVs generally have fewer moving parts, which can mean lower maintenance costs. However, battery longevity might be a concern. Hybrids, though mechanically more complex, are known for their reliability and lower upkeep compared to standard gas vehicles.

Your decision will ultimately hinge on your travel needs, the availability of charging infrastructure, and whether you prioritize eco-friendliness or convenience.

Are there any tax incentives or government benefits for South Africans buying electric vehicles?

Yes, the South African government has rolled out several incentives to promote the use of electric vehicles (EVs). One key benefit is a 150% tax deduction for investments tied to the production of electric and hydrogen vehicles. On top of that, the government has set aside 1 billion rand (approximately $54 million) to support local EV manufacturing and the production of related components. These measures are part of the Electric Vehicles White Paper, a framework designed to encourage EV adoption and boost local production efforts across the country.

Related posts

• EV Buyers in South Africa: Emissions and Behavior
• Electric vs Hybrid: Fuel Costs Compared
• Electric vs Petrol: Trends in South Africa